2023 RedHotPie Review: What We Found After Months of Use
Dating sites with risque names are all over the internet. But it’s hard to tell whether or not these sites actually work. Some are only creative as far as the site name goes, but when you start using the site, you’ll quickly learn that it’s a wasteland of fake profiles and bots. Is this the case with RedHotPie? Find out in our RedHotPie review!
To save you a bit of time, here’s a quick summary of how RedHotPie fares against one of the top hookup sites in the world–AFF:
Site
Our Experience
Our Rating
Free Trial Link
Experience Highlights
Try AFF For Free
Experience Highlights
Try RedHotPie
Licensed marriage and family therapist Lea Flego offers some great insights into men who are looking to find casual sex. “On the more enjoyable side, you can experience excitement, pleasure, and confidence. Opposingly, you can experience stress, anxiety, and sexual shame.” And now that we’ve moved into a post-pandemic world where’s its never been more difficult for single people to get their sexual needs met, more and more people have turned to hookup apps to get the job done.
Well, sort of. While the promise of easy, no-strings sex at our fingertips is an easy solution, the problem most men face is finding out which apps actually work – and which are, frankly, scams…
Fortunately for you, you’ve got writers at HeartInsider like yours truly looking out for you. I created this RedHotPie review so I can make things a bit easier for you.
It’s generally a bad idea to invest in things that won’t really help you out in the long run. This is why I decided to take the time to review RedHotPie and see what they have in store for you. I wanted to see whether this website could get you a legit hookup. As always, I tried to look at it from every angle possible and here’s what I came up with.
I’ll use this account for a few days or until I experience all the free features. Once we’re satisfied we’ve seen everything it has to offer, we upgrade to a paid account and then use that.
When using the free account, I won’t upload a profile picture nor will write a description, or anything like that. I leave the new profile totally blank so that I can see whether the site will send me spam messages. Why do I think that messages sent to an un-optimized profile are spam? Well, I mean, how many people out there really want to hook up with a person they know nothing about or haven’t even seen? Not many, I’m sure.
Once the profile has sat there blank for a couple of days, I’ll then proceed with adding both a profile picture and a brief description of myself. Once I’ve optimized the profile a bit, I’ll start using it as I would any other dating app. I usually spend a lot of time on the site so that I can find out exactly what it has to offer.
HeartInsider’ Commitment to Quality: Our Criteria for Contributors
To bring our readers a comprehensive review of dating apps like RedHotPie, every HeartInsider writer and editor follows strict and verifiable guidelines (see below). Unlike other dating sites, our reviews are always up-to-date and sourced by local experts–not rehashes of stuff you can find elsewhere.
| Aspect | Approach Description | Criteria for Writers | Editorial Standards |
| In-Depth App Reviews | We take a deep dive into dating apps, focusing on what really works for guys. We test every feature to see how it stacks up in the dating game. | Our writers are seasoned users of a variety of dating apps, with a keen eye for what makes them tick. | Editors make sure our reviews are thorough and hit all the key points without fluff. |
| Real-World Expertise | Our team brings their own dating experiences into play, giving you the lowdown on what to expect and how to make the most of each app. | Writers need to have been in the dating trenches and know how to relate that to our readers. | Editors are all about keeping it real and making sure advice is both practical and relatable. |
| Trend Tracking | The dating world is always changing, and so are we. We’re on top of the latest trends and strategies, so you’re always in the know. | Writers should be trendsetters, always up to date with the latest in the dating scene. | Editors focus on keeping content fresh, relevant, and on the cutting edge. |
| User Experience Focus | We’re not just about the technical stuff. We look at how these apps feel to use, from swiping to chatting, so you get the full picture. | Writers need to be all about the user experience, understanding what makes an app a pleasure (or pain) to use. | Editors emphasize comprehensive and empathetic reviews of the user experience. |
| Community Conversations | Your insights matter to us. We listen to what our readers have to say about their app experiences to make our reviews even better. | Writers engage with our community, using real user feedback to inform their insights. | Editors encourage a two-way conversation, making sure our content resonates with and is informed by our readers. |
Author Credentials:
Hello, my name is John Clarke. As a Dating Coach and regular contributor to HeartInsider, I’ve reviewed dozens of apps – some good, some bad, and everything in between. To help men maximize their success and avoid timewasters, I’ve created this guide to RedHotPie – chockful of useful information and my own strategies that I’ve used to find success. Drop a comment below to start the conversation today, or feel free to contact me for private consultations. Good luck!
Affiliate Disclosure:
HeartInsider.com participates in various affiliate marketing programs. This means if you click on our links and make a purchase, we may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. Our reviews and advice remain impartial and independent. Additionally, we regularly update our content to stay aligned with the ever-changing dating scene. The revenue from these commissions is reinvested to maintain the high standard of our informative content.
The Full RedHotPie Review: Is It For You?
In this article, I’m going to highlight everything you should know about RedHotPie.com. You’ll also find a short comparison between this site and AFF. Why? Because AFF (which you can try for free and see for yourself), we’ve found, is the easiest way for regular guys looking for something casual to get results (unlike Tinder). It makes for a great comparison with newer sites to see if the new option, like Red Hot Pie, is worth using.
Anyway, if you happen to be a numbers guy then we’ve got that as well too. Here’s how RedHotPie ranks up.
 |
 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Overall Our team rates each site objectively based on many hours of independent research, the features each site offers, and how it compares with other sites. The ratings are the opinion of our editors and their extensive experience. |
2 | 9.5 |
| Quality of Women Our opinion of how attractive the typical woman is that uses this site and how easy they are to connect with compared to other sites. |
1 | 9 |
| Popular How many people are using this site to actually meet people compared to other sites. |
1 | 9 |
| Usability How easy is this site to use and how quickly can an average person begin meeting people compared to other sites. |
6 | 10 |
| Privacy & Safety Does this site take proper precautions to safeguard its members, their identity, and their data. |
4 | 10 |
| Effective Our opinion of how easily an average person will be able to achieve their dating goals with this site compared to other sites. |
1 | 9 |
| Value Will the time and money spent using this site pay off for an average person based on the opinions and experience of our editors. |
1 | 10 |
The RedHotPie site generally looks really good at first glance. As far as first impressions go, it does impress from the onset. In fact, the homepage alone just makes you feel like you can definitely score after some time.
As soon as I registered and saw how everything was laid out, I immediately started feeling right at home. It doesn’t look scammy at all and it has a clean, professional and well-thought-out overall design. I didn’t even receive any spam!
There is one caveat, though: there’s no one here!
But first, the (slightly) good news…
No spam messages
For starters, just like with most other dating or hookup sites, there’s not a lot you can do on a free membership. RedHotPie’s free account is the “Guest Membership.” That being said, at least spam messages are one thing you won’t have to contend with. This is actually really refreshing considering how many other sites have taken to filling their members’ inboxes with spam messages.
Sending messages, unfortunately, is something only premium members can do. As a Guest Member, you can only send messages to your matches. Of which, once you send the first one, the next one will initiate an upgrade prompt. You’ll be asked to upgrade if you want to send another one. When you upgrade to “Premium,” you get 10 chats daily.
To get matches, you can go to the “Discover” or “Prospect” page and start swiping. Or you can get the attention of other members by sending out flirts. Also, you can block disrespectful members from viewing your profile and contacting you by reporting them to the admin.
Contacting other members is pretty straightforward
There are many different ways you can contact other members on the site. You can flirt, text chat, webchat or use a simple messaging style. Though if you’re using a Guest Membership, you only get one message per member, and that’s only with a member you’ve matched with.
Simple messaging might be the easiest and most effective way out of all of them. It’s similar to the way you’d send an email or WhatsApp text. Also, you can see your message status, whether it’s been opened already or unread. Webchat, on the other hand, gives you the ability to have virtual face-to-face conversations with other members.
You can also jump into Chat Rooms and have live text chats with other members. In this area, you can both receive and send instant messages. It works similar to the way Facebook’s Messenger app works. If you want to enter a chat room, you’ll need an Adobe Flash plug-in. But since that no longer works, there was no real way to test this feature.
But then again, looks like hardly anyone is online anyway.
If at any point you don’t feel like receiving messages, you can adjust your settings by activating the lock feature. If later on you feel like you want to start receiving messages again, unlock the lock feature and your messages will start rolling in once again. Sadly, only paying members can take full advantage of all the contacting features.
Most member profiles look legit
But then again, looks can be deceiving. At first glance, the women you’ll see on RedHotPie.com look like real women. There’s a variety of women whose looks range from average to pretty hot. But nearly none of the photos I saw seemed like they were pulled from some fashion magazine.
Here’s the thing about dating sites: it can be hard to tell if the users are legit if you don’t actually talk to any of them. Since I got ZERO replies, I wasn’t able to see if any of these profiles are legit.
Take this profile, for example:
At first glance, this looks like a real person. But when you look at her preferences right at the top, she’s searching for men aged 18-99. That’s a HUGE range, even if you’re extremely open-minded. On top of that, her “About Me” section seems rushed and not at all interesting. I’ve seen basic Tinder profiles with more thought-provoking bios!
It has some special features in case you’re getting bored
RedHotPie really doesn’t want their users to get bored it seems. The platform has some interesting features even if no one replies to your messages:
Amateur Pics. Here you can browse naughty pictures posted by other members. If you’re feeling showy and confident, you can post your own as well. In fact, you can even end up winning a cash prize if your photo gets chosen.
Nearby. You can use the app to find members located in your area. This can be done by adjusting your privacy settings to “nearby,” “vicinity” and “accurate.” Accurate members will see your location when you appear on their search results. Vicinity will just inform members that you’re in the area, while Nearby only displays your registered location (and not the current one).
Date Finder. It’s like an advanced filter where you can input all your preferences and RedHotPie will find matches for you.
Travel Plan/Date Away. If you’re planning on traveling and meeting other members when you arrive at your destination, you can schedule your dates by using this feature.
Why I think AFF is better
The bottom line? Scoring on RedHotPie is next to impossible. I messaged dozens of women (more than the usual 50 for my reviews) and still got ZERO replies. This is why I think you’re better off spending your time on .
For one, AFF is a tried, tested and battle-ready hookup platform that has millions of active subscribers. RedHotPie, on the other hand, still just has a few hundred thousand or so (with new members trickling in every few weeks). Furthermore, as much as Red Hot Pie member profiles look legit from the onset, AFF member profiles have all been scanned by the admin to ensure both catfish and scammers are kept at bay.
Secondly, the people on AFF are way more responsive and most of them are looking to hook up and meet as fast as they possibly can. Yes, just like with any other dating website, members can ghost you when they lose interest. However, at least most times you’re sure you’re communicating and interacting with real people.
To give you a more detailed look at how AFF works and how it performs for regular guys, you can also have a look at our Adult FriendFinder review.
So if you’re looking to spend time on a site where you have great odds of getting laid, then you should go the AFF route.
What people are saying about Adult Friend Finder
Tim – TrustPilot
“Adultfriendfinder.com is pretty much one of the best options and always worth a shot if you wanna get laid. Sure there are fake profiles but use your common sense and you will be fine. If you were not lucky also check out CasualsexOnly.com. Also one of the better options out there.”
u/CelebrationOk7819 – Reddit
“Been on AFF as a couple looking for married/single men. It is completely legit, have met many good people. Mostly milfs. That’s correct. The problem that I have dealt with, that makes ALOT of guys think it’s a scam, is they are not gold members. As a couple, if you can’t afford gold, then you can’t see our pics or actively chat with us… so, we will not bother. Then, the some that pay, get pushy and expect, because a woman is on there, they are expected to hook up just because they are asked. Women don’t want little dicks, guys that don’t take care of themselves etc…. with that being said, the positive reviews from men looking for females, are the guys that know how to talk, approach, bathe and have a package to offer.”
Got an opinion on AFF for dating and hookups? If so, drop a comment below and tell us what you think!
Want to learn more about AFF?
Looking for additional insights before joining AFF? HeartInsider offers a range of articles to help you understand why AFF is a great platform for initiating casual relationships. Delve into these informative guides and get the love life you deserve:
Pros and Cons From Our Review of RedHotPie
During my short stint on RedHotPie.com, I found some good and bad. Here’s what I came up with
- Good design
- Has an app version available
- Has many interesting special paid features
- No active members
- The profiles look a little fishy
- Kind of on the expensive side
Great overall design with no annoying features
RedHotPie not only has nice special features, but it provides members with a lot of functionality as well. At first glance, the homepage might look overwhelming seeing as how there’s a lot going on in one page. However, after using the platform for a bit you’ll definitely start getting used to it.
Although, the app version has a much less complicated overall layout compared to the site itself. It’s way easier to navigate because all the functionalities have been separated into two groups for every page. As far as loading time is concerned, both the app and site have medium speed responses.
The Top Alternatives To Red Hot Pie For Hookups Dating Experts Actually Recommend
If you’re serious about meeting girls there are only a few apps worth using. Most guys who fail at this are using the wrong apps to start with. Too many hookups start online for you to be making that mistake. Try these and see some results:
| Site | Our Experience | Our Rating | Free Trial Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Best Hookup Site Right Now | Experience Highlights
| 9.5 | Try AFF For Free |
Great If You're Handsome  | Tinder Highlights
| 8 | Try Tinder |
2nd Best For Most Guys  | Experience Highlights
| 8 | Try Passion |
Is RedHotPie expensive?
Honestly speaking, paid membership on RedHotPie doesn’t come cheap. They offer 3 membership packages: Platinum, Premium Plus and Premium.
Premium. Premium membership allows users to view restricted or private photos, have 2 cam views, send out 5 messages every day as well as be a 3rd priority listing on search results:
1 Month: $26.03
3 Months: $12.50/month ($37.50)
6 Months: $8.75/month ($52.50)
12 Months: $6.33/month ($75.96)
Premium Plus. This membership package gives you all the premium benefits as well as 15 additional daily messages (giving you a total of 20 daily messages). You’ll also get a 2nd priority listing and access private to chat requests and listed phone numbers
1 Month: $36.00/month
3 Months: $17.50/month ($52.50)
6 Months: $12.52/month ($75.12)
12 Months: $8.96/month ($107.52)
Platinum. This membership has 9 benefits in total. Some of these include a 1st priority listing on search results, 3 webcam views, 50 daily messages, mailbox highlighted messages and matches can message you and view the contact details you’ve listed down.
1 Month: $52.75/month
3 Months: $25.83/month ($77.49)
6 Months: $18.33/month ($109.98)
12 Months: $12.92/month ($155.04)
User Testimonial for RedHotPie
James Williams – TrustPilot
“Don’t waste your cash on chatting with robots. A few staff members are thrown in there for good measure, but mostly you receive robotic messages. There are too many red flags for fraud and there are better alternatives like good old FlingEasy.com
– now it’s my default site for turning to when I feel horny. I have tried out other sites like RedHotPie out of curiosity but they all turned out to be giant scam and time-wasters. Redhotpie is not worth a cent.”
Sanders Theodore – TrustPilot
“I recently used redhotpie.com and the whole experience was almsot good. The website was easy to navigate, and i found what i was looking for decentily quickly. I was scepticle about the website at first but it ended up being alright. Navigation was smooth, and it was fairly easy to find what i needed. That said, customer service was quite basic, so don’t exepct too much from that area. You get what you pay for! Overall its not bad, but there could be improvements for sure. Worth at least testint it out.”
Kiri – TrustPilot
“what an absolute joke of a website, been on there for a few years now, hardly any new members and tons of scammers allowed to run rife on the site, they charge ridiculous prices for membership and extra fees on top of that to send messages. Cant wait for the day this site goes out of business”
Got an opinion on RedHotPie for dating and hookups? If so, drop a comment below and tell us what you think!
Is Speed Dating Better than Dating Apps?
Is speed dating the answer instead of using dating apps like RedHotPie?
A recent study by the University of Stirling has highlighted interesting insights into speed dating, suggesting that dating apps might still hold an edge. The study, led by Dr. Anthony Lee and PhD student Amy Zhao, involved 682 participants in a speed dating scenario, providing valuable findings on attraction in face-to-face interactions.
Key Points from the Study:
- Similarity Over Opposites: Contrary to popular belief, the study found that opposites don’t necessarily attract. People with similar facial features rated each other more highly for attractiveness. Dr. Lee noted, “We found that people rated others facially similar to themselves higher.” This finding challenges the traditional speed dating approach, where diverse people meet without prior knowledge of compatibility.
- Importance of Facial Traits: The study revealed that facial masculinity and femininity are significant predictors of attractiveness in real-life encounters. As Amy Zhao explained, “These results suggest that people may seek facially similar romantic partners, as they are perceived more kind, understanding, and trustworthy.”
Why Dating Apps May Be Better:
- Broader Scope for Compatibility: Dating apps allow users to filter and match based on a wide range of preferences and similarities, offering a more curated approach to finding compatible partners.
- Avoids the Pressure of Immediate Judgment: Unlike speed dating, where decisions are made quickly and based on limited interactions, dating apps provide the space to get to know someone at a more comfortable pace.
- More Options and Flexibility: Users can engage with a larger pool of potential matches from the comfort of their home, without the constraints of time and location that come with speed dating events.
- Informed Choices: Many dating apps use algorithms and detailed profiles that provide more information upfront, allowing for informed decisions before even starting a conversation.
Conclusion? While speed dating offers the thrill of face-to-face interactions, dating apps provide a more comprehensive and pressure-free platform for finding a compatible partner.
The Anatomy of Online Dating Scams
By now, you should probably be aware that RedHotPie has the potential to scam you not only out of money, but also cause other harm.
Luckily, a little knowledge of how these scams work beforehand can prevent you from becoming a target. There’s new research out by Monica T Whitty, Head of Department of Software Systems and Cybersecurity at Monash University, that codified the five stages for online romance scams:
- “In Stage 1, the criminal creates an attractive profile to draw in the victim”
- “Stage 2, the criminal grooms the victim, priming them to send money”
- “Stage 3, the criminal begins to request funds from the victim (there a four potential trajectories at this stage)”
- “Stage 4, which only a few went through, the victim is sexually abused via cybersex”
- “Stage 5 is the revelation [of the scam]”
If you believe you’re in Stage 2 going on Stage 3, stop the interaction immediately and report the interaction with the app’s security team. Also, looking for any suspicious activity, such as the user contacting you through social media platforms, email, telephone, and so forth – all of these are clear warning signs that your information may be compromised.
Top Lies Told by Romance Scammers
According to new data released by the FTC titled “New FTC Data Reveals Top Lies Told by Romance Scammers”, there are a number of common lies that scammers use to manipulate their victims:
- “I or someone close to me is sick, hurt or in jail”
- “I can teach you how to invest”
- “I’m in the military far away”
- “I need help with an important delivery”
- “We’ve never met, but let’s talk about marriage”
- “I’ve come into some money or gold”
- “I’m on an oil rig or ship”
- “You can trust me with your private pictures”
According to the FTC’s report, “The data spotlight also highlights a growing tactic used by romance scammers: sextortion, when a romance scammer convinces a consumer to share explicit photos and then threatens to share those photos with the consumer’s social media contacts. The spotlight notes these reports have increased more than eightfold in the past three years, with consumers ages 18-29 six times more likely than older consumers to report this form of romance scam.”
Want to Avoid Other Dating App Scams? Read these articles from HeartInsider
RedHotPie: Frequently Asked Questions
We’re now at the end of our review. However, before I wrap things up completely, I’ll look at some frequently asked questions about RedHotPie.
What is RedHotPie?
RedHotPie is a hookup website that caters to basically everyone: straight, gay, transgender, bisexual and so on. The site, which also has an app, is mainly for groups, couples, women and men looking for hookups. Sadly, there aren’t enough responsive people on the site to make me recommend it.
Who actually owns RedHotPie.com?
RedHotPie.com is owned and operated by Digital Quarter Network. A company located in Australia.
How can I contact Red Hot Pie?
You can email Red Hot Pie at [email protected].
Is RedHotPie real?
Yes, RedHotPie is a real site. However, we were unable to determine if any of the users are real since none of them replied to our messages.
Is RedHotPie.com legit?
The verdict is still out on this one. On the one hand, RedHotPie.com doesn’t seem like an outright scam. I didn’t get charged extra even after my subscription has expired. However, it looks like there are hardly any users on the app. On top of that, some profiles look suspicious. I say opt for a more credible site instead.
Is Red Hot Pie a scam or fake?
Red Hot Pie doesn’t seem like a scam. The site has interesting paid features. But since there didn’t seem to be any active users on the site, we weren’t able to test them.
Is RedHotPie safe?
RedHotPie might not be a scam, but we can’t say for sure if it’s safe either. But we think it’s best if you choose a different dating site instead.
What are RedHotPie.com alternatives?
For our recommendations of the best alternatives to this site, see our extensive guide on the best hookup apps and websites.
How does Red Hot Pie work?
Once you register on Red Hot Pie, you can create your profile and browse through profiles. You can message them only with a paid account. As for other features, the site requires an Adobe Flash plug-in that no longer works.
Is there a RedHotPie app?
Yes, RedHotPie has an app on iOS.
How much does RedHotPie.com cost?
RedHotPie.com has three subscription options:
Premium:
- 1 Month: $26.03
- 3 Months: $12.50/month ($37.50)
- 6 Months: $8.75/month ($52.50)
- 12 Months: $6.33/month ($75.96)
Premium Plus:
- 1 Month: $36.00/month
- 3 Months: $17.50/month ($52.50)
- 6 Months: $12.52/month ($75.12)
- 12 Months: $8.96/month ($107.52)
Platinum:
- 1 Month: $52.75/month
- 3 Months: $25.83/month ($77.49)
- 6 Months: $18.33/month ($109.98)
- 12 Months: $12.92/month ($155.04)
How can you use Red Hot Pie for free?
Red Hot Pie doesn’t have many features that you can use for free.
Can you send messages for free on RedHotPie?
No, you need a paid RedHotPie account to send messages.
How do you delete your RedHotPie.com account?
Here’s how you delete your RedHotPie.com profile:
- Go to Profile Settings
- Select “Account settings” and “Delete profile”
References:
Chan, R. (2024) 2024 in-depth review of iHookup. Heart Insider.
Cooper, P. (2024) 2024 Fling vs AFF Comparison: Our experience using both. Heart Insider.
Federal Trade Commission (2023) New FTC data reveals top lies told by romance scammers.
Jamal, M. (2024) Spotting and avoiding Tinder scams in 2024. Heart Insider.
King, K. (2024) 2024 LocalHookup review. Heart Insider.
King, K. (2024) 2024’s best hookup apps & hookup sites we’ve tried personally. Heart Insider.
Rhodes, M. (2024) Adult FriendFinder vs Ashley madison in 2024: Which wins? Heart Insider.
Secord, L. F. (2023) How does casual sex affect mental health? Choosing Therapy.
Senkus, T. (2024) Adult FriendFinder review 2023. Heart Insider.
University of Stirling (2023) Speed dating study finds opposites don’t attract.
Whitty, M. T. (2019) Who can spot an online romance scam? Journal of Financial Crime, 26 (2). pp. 623-633. ISSN 1359-0790.
Contributing Authors:
Tom Senkus
For more than two decades, Tom has dated extensively and studied behavioral psychology as a way of understanding the complexities of human nature until he became an expert. After traveling as a touring musician and living in more than 15 countries, Tom has cross-referenced his experience in seduction, dating, and interpersonal dynamics with the ever-changing landscape of 21st-century dating. His work as a writer has appeared in 500+ publications (digital and print). Tom is also the author of several books (available on Amazon). In his free time, you can find Tom recording music and cooking the best Cincinnati-style chili you’ve ever had.
Marwan Jamal
Marwan Jamal is a dating and relationship coach for Heart Insider. Over the past several years he has worked with many of the top dating and attraction coaches to create a highly effective style all his own. He has helped many men build confidence in themselves and radically improve their ability to meet and attract women.
MJ has a Bachelor’s Degree in Marketing from Alexandria University and you have probably seen his work in the Huffington Post and The Good Men Project or in person in the many cities around the world where he’s been coaching.
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
