Let’s be honest - modern dating apps can lead to plenty of frustration. From having too many choices, poor features, a tiny pool of women users - the list goes on (and throw the pandemic in the mix!), but the struggle is real.
In the past, simply living in Wisconsin's best cities - like Milwaukee, Madison, and Green Bay - was nearly a guarantee to find some new love interest or a fun rendezvous. Or, maybe you’re studying at the University of Wisconsin-Madison or the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee and it felt like it was only a matter of time before you found someone sooner or later.
Unfortunately, those days are behind us, but there’s hope plenty of hope if you use the top Wisconsin dating apps and websites to deal with the modern dating paradigm.
There are a ton of singles using dating apps in Wisconsin
With 5.8 million residents in Wisconsin, how many of them are really using dating apps? There’s no real way to know, but we do have some stats worth considering. About 30% of Wisconsin residents are single, which means that at least half of them (around 1.7 million) are on a dating app or two. That’s good news for you because about half of those 1.7 million are women, considering Wisconsin has a pretty good man-to-woman ratio of 1:1.
If this seems like way too many figures to take in, just consider this: dating apps are one of the most popular ways to meet new people in Wisconsin. So you’re missing out big time if you don’t try at least one app!
The 5 Best Dating Sites in Wisconsin Right Now
We’re pretty picky with the apps we recommend. With hundreds of dating apps out there, we had to narrow down our list to select the best ones. So we had a look at the most popular apps, the ones with the best free and paid features, apps with the best design, and of course, dating apps that fit the culture and tastes of Wisconsin.
With these criteria in mind, the following section will help you find the best dating site recommendations for Wisconsin. Best of luck!
#1 - eHarmony (Android, iOS) is one of the best dating apps in Wisconsin for singles looking for a life-long love
Do you want to get access to a 70% chance of getting married in one year? If so, eHarmony is the best choice for dating apps in Wisconsin for long-term matches.
Unlike most dating apps, eHarmony starts the process with a detailed questionnaire and requires a paid membership. Both the length of the questionnaire and coming up with the “cover fee” of a paid membership means that you’re gaining access to people who know what they want in life. Plus, you know that most users on the app have their life together, substantially weeding out time-wasters and spam profiles.
As with dating in general, persistence and patience are key with eHarmony, but becoming one of the 7 in 10 to find the right match is worth it. Try eHarmony today!
What makes eHarmony the best dating site in Wisconsin for serious relationships?
- Highest success rate for long-term relationships
- Matches are actually matches, not just a random sampling of available Wisconsin women
- Easy to form legitimate connections based on shared interests and personality types
- Designed for serious users
What could be improved with eHarmony
- Requires a large time investment
- Users are not allowed to search for matches on their own
- Not popular with younger demographics
#2 - Hinge (iOS, Android) gives Wisconsin men access to a “hidden” pool of dates and hookups
If you’re fed up with the competitiveness of dating apps in Wisconsin like Tinder and feel that you’d do better without all the noise, Hinge is the perfect dating app for you.
With 6+ million active users, it’s likely that there’d be some overlap with other dating apps, where women are looking to meet the most men in their area.
What makes Hinge special is that it’s not the most popular app, which in turn gives you access to women that would otherwise be unavailable or hidden based on some app’s algorithm.
Pro tip: If you want a competitive advantage, try Hinge’s paid features with its “Preferred Membership” for a month to get unlimited likes, extra roses, extra gifts, and much more - all of which make you stand out from free users.
What makes Hinge one of the best dating apps in Wisconsin
- Get access to a totally new pool of women
- Less competition based on superficiality versus other apps
- Profiles highlight users’ personalities, not just their looks
What should be improved on Hinge
- The app’s design could use some work
- Not available for desktop
- There may be fewer 10/10 women on the platform
#3 - AFF is the best dating site in Wisconsin for finding casual fun
Looking for something casual or physical? AFF is the best app for Wisconsin men that want to find some friends with benefits. And because everyone on AFF is DTF, you won’t have to worry about discussing what type of fun you’re really into!
With over 60+ million users (and growing each month), search for what you’re into based on some general criteria that you’d expect from an adult website: location, age, sexual preferences, body type, and more. Best of all, AFF starts with a free trial, but most men that see success on AFF pay the affordable membership fee to really kickstart their love life.
Why AFF is a hit for Wisconsin hookups
- A substantial active user base
- Fewer people looking for an ego boost than other apps
- Well-designed interface
- Webcam options for those that want to set expectations well-before meeting in-person
What we don’t like about AFF
- Many users can only access AFF via the web ap
- AFF can feel like a “meat market” if you’re not specific about what you want
- Lots of competition for vanilla sex
#4 - Plenty of Fish (Android, iOS) is a great way for singles to meet up for dates in Wisconsin
Among dating apps in the great state of Wisconsin, Plenty of Fish (PoF) has gotten an unfortunate reputation in the past for being second-rate. From its formerly clunky design to its relatively smaller pool of users when compared to other apps and sites, PoF just seemed like it was no match for eHarmony, Tinder, and the like…
Actually, Plenty of Fish is a hidden goldmine if you think outside the box. For women users that are tired of dealing with intense competition on other apps, more and more women are turning to PoF to find a safer space to communicate with men. Tinder and OkCupid have a reputation for pushy men looking for a hookup, whereas PoF has a more discriminating user base. Plus, women that don’t get the attention on crowded apps feel more at home with PoF.
Last, PoF has a decent paid membership known as “Upgraded Profiles”, enabling men to add up to sixteen (16) pics, receive a boost in search rankings, and enable you to see who browsed your profile (great for research), and more!
Why Plenty of Fish is a great dating app
- Less competition and headaches than other apps
- Paid membership features give you more functionality than other dating apps
- Great if you’re looking for someone over 30
What could be improved
- It may not have as many top-tier profiles and attractive women that gravitate to other popular apps
- The interface feels a bit clunky
#5 - Bumble (Android, iOS) is a favorite among women
Here’s a unique one. Bumble is an app that has way more women using it than men. So what is it about the design that women love? For one thing, Bumble lets you choose your match, but guys can’t send the first message: only women can.
Why would you want to use an app that won’t let you send the first message? Simple: because women call the shots and this makes them more confident and eager to chat. It also prevents them from receiving the occasional unsolicited photo that they often get from other apps.
It might take some getting used to, especially if you’re not a patient guy, but Bumble is super popular among women in Wisconsin.
Reasons to use Bumble
- It’s free and easy to use
- Lots of women use the app
- Modern and simple site design
- Ideal for guys who don’t know how to send a good opening message
Reasons not to use Bumble
- Some women send boring opening messages like “hi”
- If a match doesn’t message you within 24 hours, the match disappears
The Best Hookup Sites in Wisconsin
With so many colleges and universities in Wisconsin, you’d think that there are plenty of hookup apps that really work. Oddly enough, we’ve tested all of them and these are the two that got us results.
AFF users know how to keep things on the down-low
While some people are open about their preference for hookups (more power to them), not a lot of people in Wisconsin are as open. Because of this, AFF makes it their mission to ensure you find some casual fun without worrying about your profile leaking to the public. So if you’re on the lookout for some seriously sexy meetups and you don’t want your friends to know about it, AFF is the site you should be using.
OkCupid is actually pretty okay
When you think of OkCupid, you might think of relationships. But in recent years, more and more people are using OkCupid to hook up. It’s a free dating app, but it does have some pretty good features that make it easy to meet a hookup partner. By filtering out your results, finding someone hot won’t be so hard. Just keep in mind that OkCupid doesn’t have as many members as bigger online dating options like Tinder and AFF.
The Best Dating Sites in Wisconsin for Serious Relationships
When it comes to dating, HeartInsider absolutely recommends eHarmony as the first choice among all other Wisconsin dating apps, with Plenty of Fish as a distant second. Let’s take a look at why eHarmony and Plenty of Fish are the best dating sites/apps in Wisconsin for finding relationships.
eHarmony is for those who absolutely know what they want
Considering Wisconsin is one of the best cities in the United States to raise a family, eHarmony is a natural choice for the state’s growing demographic. With an intuitive design and emphasis on quality matches, eHarmony is one of the best dating apps in Wisconsin that actually works. With their lengthy signup process, eHarmony is able to find an ideal match for you–one that will stick around for the long term!
Coffee Meets Bagel is for those who want to take things slow
Coffee Meets Bagel works much like eHarmony in that the app recommends matches to you every day. The difference is that Coffee Meets Bagel doesn’t have such a long signup process, and it’s also free. So if you want an app that will select matches for you but you don’t want to pay a premium, this is an app worth trying.
The Best Free Dating Apps in Wisconsin
You get what you pay for. There’s no such thing as a free lunch.
Both statements are true - even the best free dating apps in Wisconsin. While we all love a freebie, paid memberships put more functionality and better odds at your fingertips. Beat out the other guys who can’t or won’t pony up the cash and get access to features that will simplify your dating life.
On the other hand, free dating apps tend to attract more singles, especially those who are either on a budget or are unwilling to pay for a dating app. Besides the apps we’ve recommended in this article so far, the following are also some of the best free Wisconsin dating apps that we recommend:
- Coffee Meets Bagel
- Match
- Zoosk
Give these apps a try and you might just find someone today!
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
