Despite the abundance of dating sites in Maine, there’s still plenty of frustration when it comes to finding women. From too many to choose from, lack of a user base, or just apps that are a bad fit for the state, the struggle to find an app that makes dating simple can be too much.
In the past, simply living in Maine's best cities - like Portland, Old Orchard Beach, and Bangor - nearly guaranteed you’d cross paths with a lovely lady sooner or later. Or, maybe you’re studying at the University of Maine Orono or Bowdoin College and knew that you’d meet a like-minded woman between classes.
Unfortunately, the ease of in-person dating is behind us due to the pandemic and other factors, but there’s hope plenty of hope if you use the top Maine dating sites we’ve tried, tested, and recommend.
Before you read further, let us give you a quick summary of the Maine dating apps that have consistently worked for us:
| Site | Our Experience | Our Rating | Free Trial Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Best For Relationships  | Experience Highlights
| 9 | Try eHarmony |
Best For Casual Fun  | Experience Highlights
| 9 | Try AFF For Free |
Great If You're Handsome  | Tinder Highlights
| 8 | Try Tinder |
There are tons of singles using dating sites in Maine
At first glance, Maine might strike you as the northern retirement community (the southern one being Florida). True enough, lots of older people choose to live in Maine because it's a relatively safe and quiet state. But that doesn't mean living in Maine dooms you to being single forever!
With 31.19% of the adult population being single, you have plenty of single people to meet here! There are also more women than men, so if you're looking to date a woman or get into something short, fun, and casual, you shouldn't have any problems meeting them in Maine. In fact, if you use one of the dating apps and sites below, you could be looking at more dates than you know what to do with!
The 5 Best Dating Sites in Maine Right Now
We chose the best dating apps and sites in Maine based on popularity, how easy it is to find a date on each option, and how well its paid and free features work. With these criteria in mind, the following section will help you find the best dating site recommendations for Maine. Best of luck!
#1 - eHarmony (Android, iOS) is one of the best dating sites in Maine for finding relationships
Get access to a 70% chance of getting married in one year with eHarmony, the best choice for dating sites in Maine for long-term dating.
Unlike other dating sites in Maine, eHarmony starts the process with an in-depth and detailed questionnaire, plus there’s a requirement for a paid membership to engage with the app’s user base. If you’re on the fence about paying for a membership, understand that it’s like a “cover fee” that keeps out the riff-raff.
Pros of eHarmony:
- Best success rate for long-term relationships and even marriages
- Matches are actually compatible, not simply a random sampling of women
- Designed for serious users
Cons of eHarmony:
- Requires a large time investment
- Users are not allowed to search for matches on their own
- Not popular with younger demographics
#2 - Plenty of Fish (Android, iOS) is a great way for singles to chat live
One of the reasons why Plenty of Fish (PoF) is a great dating app is its Live feature. Chat instantly with Maine women on a webcam to start a conversation. Because this is a rare feature in Maine dating sites, those who are ready to engage are certain to succeed on PoF.
Also, Pof is free to use, but it does have a paid membership called “Upgraded Profiles”. For a fee the app lets you add up to 16 pictures, a boost in search rankings, and a feature that lets you see who browsed your profile, plus a lot more.
Why Plenty of Fish is a great dating app in Maine:
- Less competition than other apps
- Live feature helps avoid endless texting
- Paid membership features gives you more functionality than other dating apps
What could be improved on Plenty of Fish?
- May not have as many top-tier profiles and attractive women as other popular dating apps
- Interface feels a bit overcrowded
#3 - AFF is the best dating site in Maine to find a fun rendezvous (try it free here)
AFF is the best dating app for Maine men that want to find some fun in the bedroom. And because everyone on AFF is looking for the same thing, you never have to worry about things getting awkward.
With millions of users (60+ million), finding someone that has the same preference for fun as you do won’t be a problem. It also has a convenient search feature that further refines your search criteria (age, location, preferences, and more). AFF offers a free trial, but most men that find success on AFF shell out the cash to really jumpstart their dating life.
Why AFF is the right choice for getting down in Maine:
- Huge active user base
- Fewer people looking for an ego boost and attention than other apps
- Well-designed UX/UI interface
- Webcam options for those that want to set expectations before meeting up in-person
What could be better on AFF:
- Most users only access AFF via the web app
- AFF can feel like a “meat market” if you’re looking for vanilla fun
#4 - Coffee Meets Bagel (iOS, Android) is the top choice for many singles in the city
Maine’s reputation as Vactionland is well-deserved, even among those who call Maine home. It’s one of the reasons why the state attracts professionals. If that is your target demographic then using CMB is the right call.
Coffee Meets Bagel (CMB) is designed to be different than other dating apps you’ll find today, as it features a Bumble-like experience, daily match updates around 12 noon, and enough discoverability features to find the match near you. Paid memberships put even more features at your disposal, giving users even more parameters to meet the ambitious woman of their dreams.
What makes Coffee Meets Bagel one of the best serious dating sites in Maine:
- Upscale user base
- Much less competition than other Maine dating sites
- Paid features give you more specific search options for discoverability
What’s lacking on Coffee Meets Bagel?
- There are fewer women on the platform than on other apps
- The demographic of the app tends to fall in the 25 – 45+ age range
- The free trial only lasts a few days before limiting your chance to send Likes to profiles
#5 - Tinder (iOS, Android) is still one of the most popular dating apps out there
Tinder may be most people’s first foray into online dating, whether in Maine or any other state. It’s free and full of users, all of whom are looking for either a quick hookup or a more steady relationship.
While Tinder has lots of users even in smaller cities, it does tend to be super fast-paced. People swipe on who they’re attracted to at first glance. This could be a good thing if you’re attractive or if you have great photos. But if you’re more on the average side or if it’s your personality that really shines, you might not get as many matches.
Either way, Tinder is still worth checking out if you want to use a Maine dating app that has lots of users.
Why Tinder works:
- It’s free with paid upgrades
- Lots of attractive users
- You can change your location ahead of time if you’re traveling
- Easy and fun to use
Where Tinder is lacking:
- Tends to work better for those with good photos
- Some users are only there for attention or validation
The Best Hookup Sites in Maine
Of all the best Maine hookup sites, only AFF and Plenty of Fish actually get results:
AFF was designed for discrete fun
Maine is not the biggest state out there. To protect your reputation and privacy, AFF has a webcam feature that enables you to set expectations beforehand without having to deal with scammers, spammers, and tourists.
PoF has a live chat feature
No matter what type of dating you’re into, sooner or later you’ll want to talk face-to-face before proceeding further. PoF features a Live feature, where you can chat with matches and available women in your area to woo them - without the endless back-and-forth texting that kills attraction.
The Best Dating Sites in Maine for Serious Relationships
When it comes to dating, HeartInsider recommends eHarmony as the first choice among all other Maine dating sites, with Match as a distant second. Let’s take a look at why eHarmony and Match are the best dating sites/apps in Maine for finding relationships.
eHarmony is the right app for those who know what they want
Maine has a high standard of living, and eHarmony is the choice for individuals who want to meet their future spouses and settle down in Maine’s beautiful scenery. With an algorithm that truly works, getting quality matches with eHarmony is a guarantee.
Match helps you find matches
Match has been around for quite some time, it’s been providing quality matches since 1995. So, you can bank on the fact that Match knows what it's doing.
The Best Free Dating Sites in Maine
At HeartInsider, we like to tell the truth. And the truth is that you get what you pay for when it comes to the best free dating sites in Maine.
While we all love a freebie, paid memberships put more functionality and better odds at your fingertips. Plus, you gain a competitive edge when you pony up the cash, which is usually around $10/month - $20/month - compare that with the same amount you’d pay as a cover fee for a popular club in town.
Besides the apps we’ve recommended in this article so far, the following are also some of the best free Maine dating apps that we recommend:
- OkCupid
- Hinge
- Zoosk
Experiment with a variety of dating apps and you’ll be sure to find the right woman and relationship today!
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
